A group of elite private high schools has proposed posting a transcript of "mastery" instead of grades. Sounds great! But I fear that if there is a list of “competencies” and “skills” that elite students achieve, there will be summer boot camps and counselors advising them on how to raise their “competencies” so that their non-transcript will still stand out. It will still be a game, but a non-numeric game. ![]() How do we know what students know? How do we know which students are excellent? How do we decide which students are worthy? What is “merit”? For about a hundred years the discourse surrounding schooling in the U.S. has been obsessed with schemes and plans and analyses, grades and tests and norms and standard deviations, fights about gifted and special needs students, timed and untimed tests, and more. The competition for admission into elite colleges has gotten absurd. (Most other college admissions is not at all selective.) SAT prep courses, extra points for Advanced Placement courses, summer enrichment — all these have been used as ammunition in the college admissions war. But GPA has occupied a good deal of everyone’s attention. This summer a proposal to get away from the use of transcripts, a set of grades, has come from a new corner of the educational world: elite private high schools, together as the Mastery Transcript Consortium. Instead of grades, there would be a list of what students know and can do. I like the idea of getting away from conventional transcripts and GPAs, I really do. I’ve been experimenting with ways to get the focus off grades in my own university classes for the last several years, based on research about the nature of motivation. If the goal is to focus the students’ attention on learning, then I’m all for it. But despite the well-intentioned reasons — the lack of uniformity of students and the emphasis on nuanced mastery, competencies and skills — I am skeptical. There is still a rubric, and still a list. This has a tendency to lead to gaming the system, especially with high-stakes outcomes like admission to elite colleges. When there is a simple rubric, or even a complex rubric, there is a tendency to make this drive the experience. When my children were in junior high school, they attended a Montessori school that emphasized “mastery.” That sounds excellent, worthy. This becomes operationalized, though, in tests for which students had to achieve 85 percent. If they fell below this, they could retake the test. One of my children was completely uninterested in some of the subjects. She would take the test, see how she did, and then figure out how to raise her score to 85 percent. She did not achieve “mastery.” She achieved an empty semblance of mastery. I fear that if there is a list of “competencies” and “skills” that elite students achieve, there will be summer boot camps and counselors advising them on how to raise their “competencies” so that their non-transcript will still stand out. It will still be a game, but a non-numeric game. I have one more concern, though: This newest approach to changing high school, and therefore college admission, is reminiscent of a plan in the mid-20th-century to change college admissions at the most exclusive Ivy League colleges, and in the process to redefine “merit.” This is where we get the idea of “well-rounded” students and the emphasis on extracurriculars — a legacy we still have. The real motive, though, according to sociologist Jerome Karabel, was to exclude blacks and Jews, who had begun to excel in the measures of academic ability. So these colleges excluded students without the social and cultural capital of their traditional student body. Since college admission criteria drive the entire childhood experience, now we have wealthy students exhausting themselves to demonstrate “leadership” and “service,” along with athletic prowess, artistic and musical accomplishment, and academic stardom. Students obsess, agonize, about their grades, so anything we can do to change that is welcome. I absolutely believe the organizers of the Mastery Transcript Consortium (and I hope it is not mostly a commercial endeavor that sells the tools) that their goal is noble. But I also concur with critics that it would probably help mediocre wealthy students and hurt capable less-advantaged students. The students in less resourced schools don’t have an army of counselors and intimate relations with teachers to push them forward; they rely on something else to push them to the forefront of admissions personnel attention, which may be truly outstanding grades. The real problem is equality. With stratified high schools and huge disparities in family resources, college admissions mostly replicate the economic system. If we want to challenge inequality, we need to do it full-on. A handful of accomplished students demonstrating miraculous levels of accomplishment, against all odds, and attending elite colleges is not going to change the system, except for that handful. Meanwhile, focusing on learning rather than measurement would be a welcome change. But it would have to be in the service of more than only college admissions; it would have to refocus the nature of schooling. I hope it works! Image sources: https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/0d/95/59/0d9559d148599e4884d0c7d2097cbd97--maze-games-for-kids-games-for-kids-free.jpg http://www.saintjosephprep.org/uploaded/images/grade_grid.png
40 Comments
12/28/2017 04:28:34 am
The group of the schools is working so well and they know about their future. The role of the school is bright in this sense and I really appreciate this information.
Reply
1/29/2018 11:58:04 pm
You shared some good points of views about high school grading system. previously i read article about but i think you write the best one
Reply
2/27/2018 12:21:06 am
I really prefer your ideas about high school grading system. Grades have been and remain the center point in education, which are often accepted as the final word. It is ethical in arena where the stakes are so high. Keep it up.
Reply
4/23/2018 03:50:01 am
I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post. Now you make it easy for me to understand and implement the concept. Thank you for the post.
Reply
9/14/2018 07:13:34 am
Susan,
Reply
michele
2/8/2020 11:11:59 am
B-aloney this is all part of Agenda 2030 and planning the economy stopy lying about 'why' you created the MTC.
Reply
10/18/2018 04:07:27 am
Can I just say what a relief to find someone who actually knows what they are talking about on the internet. You definitely know how to bring an issue to light and make it important. More people need to read this and understand this side of the story. I cant believe you are not more popular because you definitely have the gift.
Reply
11/15/2018 02:06:04 am
Thank you for the info which is very useful for every time
Reply
1/14/2019 04:59:45 am
Cara membuat akun togel yang cepat dan benar di situs judi togel online yang terpercaya SukaBet.
Reply
4/27/2019 12:17:16 am
Bagi anda para pencinta Judi Online anda dapat membaca informasi cara bermain beserta trick - trick menang hingga ratusan juta dalam bermain semua Jenis Permainan Judi Online. Anda bisa melihat nya pada link berikut ini
Reply
Judi Online sekarang ini semakin menarik. Dengan hadiah yang besar dan modal yang kecil, resiko yang anda dapatkan sangat kecil. Yuk langsung bermain di dewaasia!
Reply
4/30/2019 04:26:35 am
I believe that is one of the so much vital
Reply
5/1/2019 10:30:22 pm
Akses Mudah serta beragam bonus di SUKABET.CO yang diberikan oleh kami kepada Anda. Kami adalah Game Slot Online terbaik di Indonesia yang sudah verified. Kenyamanan member menjadi Prioritas kami dan kami berkomintmen supaya semua pemain Judi Online selalu mendapatkan keuntungan.
Reply
5/27/2019 03:45:44 am
SukaTogel Agen Togel Terpercaya yang sudah 4 tahun melayani para pemain togel di indonesia maupun di asia. Suka Togel menyediakan berbagai game mulai dari Togel Singapore, Togel hongkong, togel cambodia, togel shenzhen dan masih banyak pilihan permainan lainnya.
Reply
7/4/2019 03:16:32 am
Bagi anda para pencinta Judi Online anda dapat membaca informasi cara bermain beserta trick - trick menang hingga ratusan juta dalam bermain semua Jenis Permainan Judi Online. Anda bisa melihat nya pada link berikut ini
Reply
10/24/2019 01:08:16 am
agen judi online terbaik dan terpercaya dengan minimal deposit 10rb hanya di pokercuan yang juga memberikan bonus new member sampai 50% yang diberikan di awal pada saat deposit
Reply
10/26/2019 04:23:34 am
Bermain di situs resmi togel terpercaya akan mendapatkan banyak keuntungan dalam jangka panjang, dengan modal yang sangat minim akan dilipatgandakan hingga 1000x lipat dari modal yang ditaruhkan. Silahkan join di situs togel resmi kami
Reply
imyoona
1/17/2020 03:12:58 am
Thanks gan, materinya sangat bermanfaat sekali ^^
Reply
1/29/2020 10:10:58 pm
Bagi anda para penggemar permainan judi togel online, Berikut ini adalah beberapa tips dan trick jitu dalam bermain judi togel untuk menang hingga jutaan rupiah setiap hari nya
Reply
2/3/2020 01:25:09 am
Bagi anda para penggemar permainan judi togel online, Berikut ini adalah beberapa tips dan trick jitu dalam bermain judi togel untuk menang hingga jutaan rupiah setiap hari nya
Reply
2/3/2020 01:28:42 am
Bagi anda para penggemar permainan judi togel online, Berikut ini adalah beberapa tips dan trick jitu dalam bermain judi togel untuk menang hingga jutaan rupiah setiap hari nya
Reply
4/27/2020 08:08:07 pm
For about a hundred years the discourse surrounding schooling in the U.S. has been obsessed with schemes and plans and analyses, grades and tests and norms and standard deviations, fights about gifted and special needs students, timed and untimed tests, and more. The competition for admission into elite colleges has gotten absurd. (Most other college admissions is not at all selective.) SAT prep courses, extra points for Advanced Placement courses, summer enrichment — all these have been used as ammunition in the college admissions war. But GPA has occupied a good deal of everyone’s attention.
Reply
5/28/2020 07:27:07 am
cara mendapatkan bonus melimpah di situs poker online terpercaya
Reply
8/19/2020 04:38:00 am
tv-off merupakan situs resmi Indonesia yang menyediakan sebuah permainan judi slot online terpopuler yang dapat diakses dalam satu akun dan dengan modal saldo awal cukup idr 20 ribu. Buat anda yang tertarik dan ingin bermain judi slot online seperti Joker123,Pragmatic,PP Slot, Spade Gaming, Flow Gaming, Micro Gaming, PT Slot. Habanero, PG Soft, Playngo, CQ9, GGSlots kami merekomendasikan tv-off untuk dijadikan situs andalan bermain judi slot secara online dan tentunya tanpa Bot
Reply
10/9/2020 04:18:30 am
Merupakan agen terpercaya yang memiliki banyak sekali permainan slot hingga 1000+, dan juga memiliki permainan lainnya seperti poker, casino, bola, arcade dll.
Reply
10/9/2020 04:19:59 am
kami adalah wadah judi slot online yang bekerjasama denga berbagai provider ternama seperti Pragmatic Play, Spadegaming, Habanero, Joker123, Microgaming dan yang lain yang bisa kalian mainkan dengan deposit awal termurah se asia IDR 20K
Reply
1/22/2021 01:24:45 am
tempat bermain judi slot uang asli terlengkap dengan piihan platform paling populer seperti Joker123 Hanabero Pragmatic Play dan masih banyak lagi lainnya.
Reply
1/23/2021 02:11:12 am
Tempat bermain judi slot terlengkap dengan dukungan langsung dari puluhan platform terpopuler seperti Joker123, Pragmatic Play, Hanabero dan masih banyak lagi lainnya.
Reply
slot adalah game online ajaib yang mampu mencetak uang secara instan, ribuan bettor tengah ramai memainkan game judi online slot pada situs resmi berlisensi, silahkan kunjungi link webisite dibawah ini :
Reply
Lastprivate
2/5/2021 12:12:47 am
kami sebagai situs judi slot online terbaik dan terpercaya di tahun ini memberikan berbagai permainan terlengkap dengan winrate yang tidak rendah, marilah bergabung sekarang juga dan untuk info lebih lanjut silakan kunjungi link dibawah ini:
Reply
3/4/2021 03:40:52 am
Slot online merupakan sebuah permainan yang paling menguntungkan di tahun ini, segera bermain sekarang juga dan nikmati semua permainan slot online hingga 1000+ yang telah tersedia di dalamnya.
Reply
5/7/2021 12:55:44 am
https://creator.ionic.io/share/9baf41042892
Reply
11/17/2021 01:03:40 am
Good Articel Please visit my site;)
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
Archives
May 2021
Categories
All
|